skip to main content

A grizzly bear sitting in the water in the intertidal zone

Raincoast’s Efforts:

Northern Gateway and the NEB Hearings

Raincoast was an intervener in the National Energy Board’s (NEB) public review process, known as the Joint Review Panel (JRP), on Enbridge’s Northern Gateway Pipeline project, represented by our legal counsel, Ecojustice.

The following is a brief overview of our work against the Northern Gateway Project in our efforts to keep our coast oil-free.

In 2004: Raincoast begins 5 years of systematic ocean surveys to document the presence, abundance and distribution of marine birds and mammals to inform the debate and growing pressure on the BC coast for oil  development.

In 2009: Raincoast completed 7 seasons, 14,000 kilometres of survey trackline compiling over 2000 ‘sightings’ of marine mammals and 20,000 ‘sightings’ of marine birds.

In 2010: Raincoast publishes scientific papers on preliminary results, a technical report, and a popular report: What’s at Stake: the Cost of Oil on BC’s Priceless Coast

What's at Stake: the Cost of Oil on BC's Priceless Coast cover

View published scientific papers to date

Download the technical report:  Predictive Marine Mammal Modelling for Queen Charlotte Basin, British Columbia (PDF)

Download the popular report What’s at Stake?: the Cost of Oil on BC’s Priceless Coast (PDF)

 

In 2010: Enbridge filed their proposal with the NEB.  The proposal (i.e. Environmental and Socio-economic Assessment or ESA) and its many updates can be downloaded from the NEB’s website.  The volumes that Raincoast reviewed can be downloaded below.

In 2011: Raincoast filed as a formal intervener with the NEB to participate in the JRP process.

In 2011: Raincoast filed the first round of Information Requests to Enbridge and the Canadian Federal government

In 2011: Raincoast made a lengthy submission of evidence to the Joint Review Panel critiquing aspects of Enbridge’s pipeline, marine terminal and tanker proposal, specifically as they relate to impacts on wildlife.  Our review revealed severe inadequacies with the assessments, models and analysis in Enbridge’s Environmental and Socio-economic Assessment (ESA).

Download Raincoast’s Submission of Evidence (PDF), or individual chapters separately:

In July 2012:  Raincoast received questions from Enbridge regarding our submission of evidence.  Some were legitimate questions regarding the evidence presented, while others were puerile jabs that had no relevance to the submission, the material in front of the JRP panel or the NEB process.

Download Enbridge’s Information Request & Raincoast’s Response (PDF)

In November 2012:  Enbridge lawyers cross examine Raincoast scientists on our terrestrial evidence submission. Download November 2012 Transcripts (pdf).

In December 2012: Legal counsel for Raincoast (and its partners) began cross examination of Enbridge on the marine component of Enbridge’s ESA. Download December 2012 Transcripts (pdf) (Tim Leadem X).

In February 2013: Raincoast’s legal counsel, Ecojustice, continue cross examination on the marine component of Enbridge’s ESA. Download February 2013 Transcripts (pdf) (Karen Campbell X).

In March 2013: Raincoast’s legal counsel, Ecojustice, continue cross examination on the marine component of Enbridge’s ESA.  Download March 2013 Transcript’s (pdf) (Barry Robinson X).

In April 2013: Enbridge cross examines Raincoast scientists on our marine submission of evidence and critique of their ESA. However, at the 11th hour, Enbridge withdraws their request to cross examine 90% of Raincoast’s submission. Severe critiques of Enbridge’s work to assess impacts to salmon, herring, eulachon, marine birds, and from the terminal, oil tankers and cumulative effects, stand unchallenged.  Download April 2013 Transcripts (pdf).

In April 2013: with Raincoast providing scientific support, our legal counsel, Ecojustice, cross examined two departments of Canada’s federal government, Fisheries and Oceans Canada and Environment Canada, on the marine components of Enbridge’s ESA April 2013 Transcripts (pdf) (Tim Leadem X).

In early June 2013: Raincoast and our JRP coalition partners submitted Final Written Arguments (pdf) in the hearings.

In mid June 2013, Raincoast’s legal counsel, Ecojustice, presented our Final Oral Arguments (pdf) (delivered by Barry Robinson) in response to Enbridge’s final arguments.

In late June 2013: the hearings conclude.

In December 2013: the JRP panel makes its recommendations to Stephen Harper’s cabinet.

All of Raincoast’s submissions and correspondence, and those of our JRP coalition partners, Forest Ethics and Living Oceans Society, can be viewed by searching the NEB’s website.

Enbridge’s Submission to the National Energy Board (reviewed by Raincoast)

Terrestrial

Volume 6A: ESA Pipeline and Tank Terminal Part 1 (pdf)

Volume 6A: ESA Pipeline and Tank Terminal Part 2 (pdf)

Volume 6C: ESA Human Environment (pdf)

Volume 7A: ESA Construction, Environmental Protection and Management Plan (pdf)

Volume 7B: ESA Risk Assessment and Management of Spills – Pipelines (pdf)

TDR Terrestrial Wildlife Data and Field Surveys (pdf)

TDR Vegetation (pdf)

TDR Enbridge Wildlife Habitat Models (pdf)

Marine

Volume 6B: ESA Marine Terminal (pdf)

Volume 7C: Risk Assessment and Management of Spills  – Kitimat Terminal (pdf)

Volume 8A: ESA Overview and General Information – Marine Transportation (pdf)

Volume 8B: ESA – Marine Transportation (pdf)

Volume 8C: Risk Assessment and Management of Spills -Marine Transportation (pdf)

TDR Weather and Oceans Conditions (pdf)

TDR Coastal Mapping in CCAA (pdf)

TDR Coastal Mapping OWA (pdf)

TDR Risk Assessment of Spills (pdf)

TDR Properties and Fate from Spills at OWA (pdf)

TDR Properties and Fate from Spills at CCAA (pdf)

TDR Marine Physical Environment (pdf)

TDR Marine Mammals (pdf)

TDR Marine Birds (pdf)

TDR Freshwater Fish and Fish Habitat (pdf)

TDR Marine Fisheries (pdf)

TDR Marine Ecological Risk Assessment for Kitimat Terminal (pdf)

TDR Marine Acoustics 2006 (pdf)

TDR Marine Acoustics Modelling Study 2010 (pdf)

Updates

General Oil Spill Response Plan March 2011 (pdf)

TERMPOL Updates Summary (pdf)

TERMPOL_TDR Vapour Cloud Modelling and Conditional QRA  (pdf)

TERMPOL_TDR Hydrocarbon Mass Balance Estimates (pdf)

TERMPOL_TDR Manoeuvring Study plus Appendices (pdf)

TERMPOL_Surveys and Studies (pdf)

TERMPOL TDR Marine Shipping QRA (pdf)